Thanks so much for submitting a report. It has been emailed to the Rum Captain and will be actioned shortly.
Over a year ago I reviewed Plantation XO from Barbados. I was excited when I found it at a big liquor warehouse. But it was a different bottle and different experience. Sill a very good rum. But not as I reviewed in 2015. Until now I hadn't realized the bottle that showed up in my review cabinet was not what I had reviewed.
I'm posting a photo showing both bottles. I'm still not sure what the difference is? Both are 20th anniversary edition. Both are XO but no specific age. Both are Barbados rum. Reading all the reviews of both bottles, it appears that many reviews 'may' be posted under the incorrect bottle design. There's no way to know it, unless you really study the bottle but the details are the same. If anyone has addressed this I haven't seen it. I'll probably start a new forum thread in search of an explanation.
The rum I Prefer and gave a 9 to is the shorter, squater bottle without the string/rope mesh around the bottle.
The bottle with the mesh is slightly less sweet. It is darker, than the honey gold of the shorter bottle. It doesn't have as much complexity. It's still a decent sipper but falls short of great.
Here's my original review. It is for the shorter, squater, empty:-( bottle on the left.
This is a very complex rum. It's not overly sweet and through the aging process used it does share some characteristics of Cognac. There is a fair amount of oak for a rum. Vanilla, caramel and I think I'm picking up coconut and even chocolate. There's no burn and a long finish. If you're going to spend the money know your rums or you won't appreciate this as much as it deserves!
One of my favorites, very sweet and a very distinct flavor of coconut. Simply really smooth and enjoyable straight up.
As far as I can see this is the same as the "Plantation XO 20th Anniversary" found on this site, so I'm giving the same rating on both.
Smooth, warm and delicious! Exceptional value. Great neat or an ice cube.
Picked this beauty up while in Barbados a couple of months ago. Not sure I have ever sampled a rum aged in french wine casks.
In a word, decadent. Insanely smooth from start to finish, not chewy as sweeter rums can be and not gaggingly dry. This belongs on the same shelf with the world's greatest digestifs. I will weep win this bottle is no more.
Best sweet rum so far, better than diplomatico reserva in my opinion.
Was excited to open this little number. Good yes but not great. As a Barbados XO I was expecting greater complexity.
I was pleasantly surprised when I first sipped on this. It delivers a heavy tropical hit, not in a dos maderas luxus rich and heavy kind of way but in a fruity coconut, spice and vanilla driven way that is smooth, aromatic and lingering on the palate. A different rum for those that want.. well.. something different.
This rum is just perfect for me, its is smooth, sweet, with almost no burn. It beats appleton estate, wich is much more expensive. Really good sipping rum!!
I love Plantation Rums. And this one is by far the best one. It's smooth and sweet and it's so tasty. I could have one right now. I tried more expensive Rums, but they weren't as good as the XO.
I love Plantation Rums. This rum has great rummy taste, caramel, vanilla in body and finishes nice. For price I tend to drink Diplomatico Reserva Exclusive, Ron Zacapa Solera and Rumson's Grand Reserve more. I prefer them a bit more and half the price, but this rum is still fantastic. I also love the 5 year old Barbados version for a great deal.
Perfekt! Der ganze Geruch und Geschmack der Karibik in einem Glas Rum!
A very easy and sweet rum: ripe fruit and coconut, with some vanilla. One of my favourites!
Heel lekker, zacht, prefect na een zware maaltijd. De ideale afsluiter.
A good sipper, but very sweet. Not sure this will be a go-to rum for me, but I'll dutifully finish off the bottle and keep searching for something that comes close to Pampero.
Very nice and smooth but I don't think that it's worth the high price. There are cheaper rums that are just as nice.
This rum really nails it for me.
Nice & sweet, but not too much
Complex rummy flavour
Fruity coconut hints
You really get a taste of the Caribbean here, simply fantastic.
I liked the diplomatico reserva exclusica but this one exceeds it in my opinion. He is perfectly balanced in his strength and sweetness. A true delight!
I had the opportunity to taste this good rum from Barbados. Clasic, off-swet rum, with medium intense citrus nose, harmonic and enjoyable warm rum. Very long, integrated alkohol.
Good stuff for being Plantation. A sipping rum with a Big palate
Along the lines of most plantation rums. Smooth with candy like notes but you get a nice toffee bouquet taste. Very smooth with no bitter or heat down the throat. Well worth the awards
This is a hidden treasure it is a real wonderful sipper. Maybe one Ice cube ? (not). I just like adding time, let it rest and enjoy.
All the best
Nothing overly exciting but aged to a very high quality.
Very smooth, buttery after taste. I could easily have this drink all night.